Idaho Press-Tribune

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Not you?||
Logout|My Dashboard

Be honest about why you’re not debating

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Friday, May 7, 2010 12:15 am

The primary election is 18 days from today. There aren’t too many contested races among the Democrats (there seldom are in Idaho), but there are oodles of candidates in the Republican primaries.

Such is the case with the race for governor. Incumbent Butch Otter has five opponents in the primary: Sharon Ullman, Rex Rammell, Tamara Wells, Walt Bayes and Ron “Pete” Peterson.

Recent polling indicates Otter would receive about 60 percent of the vote over Democrat Keith Allred in November, so it stands to reason he has nothing to gain by appearing in a televised debate with his GOP opponents. If anything, he runs the risk of making a gaffe or looking indecisive when asked a question — something his opponents could pounce on to boost their campaigns.

Like a football team with a 40-point lead in the fourth quarter, it makes no sense to take chances. Just run out the proverbial clock. So at least from a strategic standpoint, you can’t blame Otter for turning down debate requests.

Not surprisingly, his opponents aren’t happy. They’re saying the governor isn’t giving voters a fair chance to hear the candidates’ views on important matters. They believe Otter’s absence will result in fewer viewers. And considering many of these candidates have little money on which to campaign, televised debates are their only real chance to reach a large percentage of the voters.

You can’t blame them for crying foul. Nor can you blame Otter for not participating, but you can take issue with the flimsy reason he gave. He sent a letter to the organizers of the May 18 Idaho Public Television debate sponsored by the League of Women Voters and Idaho Press Club saying he wasn’t participating because Wells, Bayes and Peterson weren’t invited. Those candidates didn’t get invites because they didn’t respond to requests for information about their campaigns or didn’t meet criteria indicating they were running active campaigns.

The governor even took a poke at IPTV, saying since it gets public funding, it should invite all the candidates, regardless of how viable they may be.

Oh, please.

Otter has the right to decline the invitation, but he should be forthright about why. And it seems far-fetched to believe that it’s out of fairness to a few fringe candidates.


© 2015 Idaho Press-Tribune. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Check out these other popular articles

  LOCAL ROUNDUP: NNU golf teams sweep on historic day
Northwest Nazarene’s Keynan Fanslow matched a school record set by teammate Michael Delie a day earlier for the NNU men’s team, while the Crusader women picked up its first team title since starting the program three years ago, as NNU swept team titles at the NNU Invitational Tuesday at Rigecrest Golf Club.
  Senate kills House tax proposal
BOISE — In a whirlwind day of legislative action, the Idaho Senate heard the House’s large tax and transportation proposal in committee and killed it on the floor in a matter of hours.

Welcome to the discussion.


  • brickwall posted at 11:15 pm on Fri, May 7, 2010.

    brickwall Posts: 2

    Well written editorial. I agree totally.

  • JC0775 posted at 3:42 pm on Fri, May 7, 2010.

    JC0775 Posts: 18

    Butch Otter is a "Good 'Ol Boy," and likesto play his politics that way. I like some of his stances and policies. I am overall moderately pleased with his term as governor, but this move wreaks of elitism. I think my opinion of Butch is more common than he would like to admit. Listen up Butch, moderately pleased can turn to moderately displeased in an instant. All it takes is an elitist attitude that tells the voters you take them for granted for you to join the ranks of the unemployed. I think you had better hire a new adviser or start planning your retirement.


e-Newsletter Signup

Sign up today to receive breaking news and daily email headlines every morning.

Opinion Poll