Idaho Press-Tribune

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Not you?||
Logout|My Dashboard

Frat house fall lawsuit against UI dismissed

Frat house fall lawsuit against UI dismissed

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Tuesday, August 14, 2012 12:41 pm | Updated: 12:07 am, Wed Aug 15, 2012.

MOSCOW, Idaho (AP) — A civil lawsuit against the University of Idaho filed by a former student who fell from a frat house window during an off-campus party and suffered debilitating injuries has been dismissed.

Second District Judge Michael Griffin tossed the suit brought by Amanda Andaverde of Caldwell and her parents in a written ruling issued Friday. The Moscow-based university, which recently rejected a $1 million settlement proposed by Andaverde and her family, issued a statement Monday saying it was pleased with the ruling.

"This was a tragic accident and our hearts continue to go out to Amanda and to her family and friends," the school said. "However, we believe the court is correct in its ruling that the university and our governing board were not proper parties to the damage claims brought by Amanda and her parents."

Andaverde was a 19-year-old sophomore when she fell from an upper story window during a Sigma Alpha Epsilon frat house party. Andaverde fractured several bones and also suffered a traumatic brain injury.

In court, an attorney for the family argued that the university was liable for Andaverde's injuries because it oversees the fraternity and sorority system on campus. Also, the family's attorney said the university, which maintains policies against underage drinking, encourages students to live in so-called Greek organizations and has the ability to enforce sanctions against them.

A lawyer for the university countered that school officials can't control what students do on private property and shouldn't be held liable for accidents. Additionally, the university said Andaverde was in a privately owned Greek house and acting as an adult when she chose to consume alcohol the night of her fall.

Griffin granted the university's motion seeking to dismiss the case in a written ruling.

He agreed that the university didn't have what the law calls a "special duty to aid or protect" Andaverde under the circumstances spelled out in the case.

"The plaintiffs have not presented sufficient evidence, even when viewed in the light most favorable to the plaintiffs, to establish that the University owed a duty to Ms. Andaverde," Griffin said. "Without such a showing the plaintiffs' claim of negligence would not be meritorious."

A decision on whether to appeal the ruling is pending, said the Andaverde family's attorney, Warren Dowdle.

The family's legal claims against Andaverde's former sorority, Delta Delta Delta, the Sigma Alpha Epsilon fraternity and several unnamed individuals are still pending.


Information from: Lewiston Tribune,

© 2015 Idaho Press-Tribune. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Check out these other popular articles

  LOCAL ROUNDUP: Steelheads let Grizzlies pull even in series
T.J. Syner finished off a two-on-one rush midway through the third period and the Utah Grizzlies held on late as William Wrenn’s last-second shot skipped just wide of the post in the final seconds, as Utah beat the Idaho Steelheads 3-2 on Friday in Game 2 of the ECHL Western Conference Quarterfinals in West Valley City, Utah.
  NNU board to formally review layoffs
NAMPA – After Northwest Nazarene University’s faculty voted to express “no confidence” in President David Alexander’s leadership, the school’s Board of Trustees on Friday vowed to formally review a $1.3 million budgetary decision that left popular professor Thomas Oord without a job.
NAMPA — When Robert Fleming was pulled out of a five-year prison sentence and assigned instead to Canyon County’s brand-new veterans court in April 2012, his program required him to complete 20 hours of community service.

Welcome to the discussion.

e-Newsletter Signup

Sign up today to receive breaking news and daily email headlines every morning.