DIY Diva
Welcome GuestLog in  Register
Online: 0 members and 163 guests.
Keyword 
Vickie Schaffeld-Holbrook
Sunday, September 13, 2009 - 10:26 pm
Image not available.

Words escape me. Dan Vickery and Antonio Ballatore both did amazing jobs with the final challenge on HGTV's Design Star, but in the end, the judges decided that Antonio would have his own show. We'll see his first on HGTV next week when he makes over his own home.

Want to catch up with what others are saying? See my roundup in today's post and check back for more of my own thoughts later today.

But the journey isn't over for Dan. For starters, everybody needs to vote for Dan at HGTV's site. The winner of that online voting gets his/her own online show on HGTV. Dan would be awesome. So get out and vote early and often through Tuesday.

Because Dan knew the outcome, he answered some questions I posed to him and sent them to me when the show ended so I could share them with you. Dan's had a lot of time to think about this and we — all his fans — are just now having to process the fact that Antonio won. Dan won in so many ways. And he has a very bright future ahead of him. Watch for most blog postings later tonight and tomorrow. In the meantime, here's what Dan had to say.

How did it feel when you knew the final outcome?

The funny thing is I knew the final outcome before it was announced. Clive is a professional host and played the part to the 'T'. The announcer, however, had a little trouble with his lines and we shot the scene when he came into the elimination room at least 4 times, maybe more. He couldn't take his eyes off of Antonio the entire time and I knew then my name would not be called.

It had been a long and hard journey and I was proud of what I had done. At this point in the competition there is so much more being judged than simply design and hosting. I gave my all for this competition and was able to walk off that stage proud.

What did you think about the judges comments?

Antonio and I both had different strengths and weaknesses in this challenge. I really feel that their critiques were fair and honest.

Why do you think Antonio won?

Antonio and I were compared and contrasted from the beginning. We had some very similar strengths and some very different personalities. We talked about how my personality was a great fit for the HGTV family and that could also be my greatest weakness. Antonio had the opposite issue which was apparently a strength for him.

You mentioned before that it was a big challenge. How intense was the final challenge?

Because the challenge was so large it had as much to do with organization and communication as it did actual design. We were each working with a team of 6 carpenters. Some of them we had met on previous challenges but most of them were new. We had to put a lot of faith in their ability to understand our concepts and carry them out. I spent a lot of time each night working on drawings and written instructions for my team to be sure they had a clear vision of my design concepts while I out shopping.

I had a great crew and a couple of really spectacular guys who took the lead while I was away. Thank you to my entire crew but especially to Stephen and Randy.

How gratifying was the whole experience?

Extremely gratifying. It is amazing to look back and think I came so close without winning but there are so many things to be positive about. I had a dream and I went for it! After being told no last year I never slowed down. I was the youngest competitor besides Nathan and competing against someone who has been doing design for thirty years compared to my five. I had great moments with design and was able to share that with America. I kept my integrity and stayed honest throughout the competition, regardless of what editing may have you believe. I also made some friends I will have for life, Lonni in particular. She is an amazing woman.

What happens now for Dan Vickery?

I am waiting for September 15th and hoping that I will be the fan favorite. I still dream of having my own design show. That's been the goal for almost ten years now and I have only been encouraged to continue on this path. If I cannot achieve my dream with HGTV I will find another way.

Was the experience worth it?

Definitely. Especially because of my age I can only go up from here. I learned a lot and had a lot of fun. I also made some great connections and got some wonderful exposure. I feel great about my future.

Would you do it again? Or recommend someone else to try it?

Knowing everything I know now, yes, I would definitely do it again. I cannot imagine this will have anything but a positive impact on my life. I would also say that if it is your dream you have to go for it. An amazing opportunity is out there and it will change your life. Who wouldn't you go for it?

Can you talk about your future with HGTV?

I am sure you will see my face on HGTV again. They have brought back past finalist's from Design Star for Showdown's and even had them help with some special promotions. I cannot make any guarantees but things are looking positive.

Anything we missed on the season finale?

My family is my foundation and my best friends. Like past seasons they did bring our families into see us the morning of the final challenge. Somehow that footage never made it on the air. The day before my family flew down my Grandpa Don, my dad's father, passed away. With everything going on at home my parents and my sister still came down for me. They went against their instincts when the producers told them to tell me about it.

As wonderful as it was to see my family it was still tough news to hear. I broke down and remained a wreck the entire first day of the challenge. I quickly changed my attitude and fought for my dream. This was certainly no time to give up.

I would have loved to share my family with America. They are a huge part of who I am. My sister's strength and humor. My mom's will and insight. My dad's patience and of course his laugh, exactly like mine.

Because the challenges really do go by as quickly as they seem to on TV I was able to make it home in time for my grandpa's funeral and spend time with my family.

Dan, anything else you want to mention or say?

Overall I feel the competition was a success. I am happy to have it done and no longer have this secret to hide even though it has been one of the most exciting secrets of my life. I have surprised myself and am very proud of my accomplishment.

I want to thank the judges. They each had things to teach us throughout the competition and I know I am a better designer because of it. Thanks also to HGTV for the exciting opportunity and for remembering me from Season 3 auditions and giving me another chance. Thank you especially though for all the people who have stood by me and believed in me. Thanks also to my fans. It is still strange thing to think that I have fans but I am thrilled with their support.

Bookmark and Share

Comments:

Dan, You showed amazing integrity and strength of character. And you come across as so genuine unlike those folks at HGTV. Congrats Dan!! I'll be looking forward to your online program. You most certainly, without question should have won Design Star.
sunfire - 8:40 PM, Friday September 18, 2009
Dan--you're the best. I really miss watching Design Star this week and that's because I miss watching you, Antonio and Lonni duke it out. Best top three in the show ever. Your thoughtfulness and kindness certainly came through every week. Best of luck to you!
Miss Lisa - 10:25 AM, Wednesday September 16, 2009
Dan, I am still rooting for you and I hope that you eventually do get a show (whether at HGTV or elsewhere). I will love to see some more of your work. You are one of the best designers out there and so nice to everyone whom you worked with. I also voted for you and will tune in!!!!! Love ♥
beautyhasgrace - 8:29 PM, Tuesday September 15, 2009
Dan, first let me offer my condolences on the passing of your beloved grandfather. It's amazing to me that you performed so beautifully in the final challenge, even while bearing that burden of grief, which your viewers never saw. What a true professional you are! Like many other HGTV fans, I am sorely disappointed that you are not the next Design Star. Your designs were clearly better than Antonio's in every way and your on-screen hosting was wonderful, giggles and all! I personally loved the giggle and thought it made you so endearing. Apparently, I'm not the only one who adored you and your designs, as there are thousands of angry fans expressing their outrage at the HGTV blogs, and I was one of them! I've also been voting for you every day as the fan favorite, and I'm sure many others are, too, so I hope you'll win the online show. If the HGTV execs are smart, they'll give you an on-air show, too! In any case, I hope to see your handsome, smiling face and your beautiful, elegant designs on TV again real soon. Much love and many blessings for a long and successful career. Dan's the Man! :)
Cee618 - 12:30 AM, Tuesday September 15, 2009
Dan, I knew you were the champion since the white room challenge. I feel you have a true designer concept, and you're not a gimmick. Everyone knows that you will find success from this adventure, and that it is well deserved. Not only are you a fantastic designer - but you seem like a truly great, honest, and genuinely kind person. I have voted for you online, and will do so again. We wish you all the best - "a Dan fan"!
Jennifer D - 10:54 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
I wish HGTV would post a public pole asking who the viewing audience would like to watch on tv. I would really appreciate it if they would give Dan the tv show he earned :)
Beth - 9:48 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
DAN is clearly America's choice by a longshot. With their recent (and obvious) edict to stir things up with conflict, melodrama, and overly-aggressive TV "hosts", HGTV, from Vern Yip up through the ranks to the top executives, have made an epic blunder in giving the Soprano guy a thumbs up. Not out of spite or "sour grapes", but because I dislike the other guy's personality, and fail to see his design talent, I would not allow him into my home, much less choose to see his mug on my TV screen. Sadly, the direction that HGTV has chosen, moving towards tabloid-style programming, will limit my viewing to the few remaining shows that still combine quality entertainment and useful information. DAN, YOU ARE THE TRUE WINNER, and now you are free to move forward to secure your place not only in the world of design, but in the hearts and minds of millions.
DesignABCs - 9:30 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
Dan, Dan, Dan. I could not sleep last night after seeing Antonio win. What a joke. Not only were your designs FAR superior to anything he did, but your personality, your intelligence, your laughter, your everything was like comparing the ocean to a mud puddle. HGTV really messed up with this & I know it has caused a permanent rift between many devoted viewers & them. Thankfully you seem to recognize that this was a cheap reality-TV trick & no reflection on your abilities. As you can tell from the irate comments being posted on HGTV's blog, 90% of viewers are not simply disappointed, they are furious at the outcome. On another note, I was saddened to hear of your grandfather's passing, esp. at such a critical time. I lost my precious Mom a short time ago & I know the pain. Dan, you are an absolutely amazing person and I hope somehow this experience ends up opening doors for you that will far surpass your wildest imagination. When my husband saw my face last night, he knew instantly that Antonio had won. I sarcastically said "I wonder what places they'll have him designing?" & my hubby said "oh, cemeteries, courtrooms, and bars." Sounds about right to me. Big hugs, Dan. In spite of what the powers to be at HGTV decided, you WERE the winner. Your designs were absolutely breathtaking.
dana - 4:40 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
Dan, Babe(altho not a babe),we love you. wish i was there to give you and your family a big ol'Texas hug. I was rottin for you all along and will be voting for you today and tomorrow After the shaow last nite i was so upset and was crying for you because of your "pain of losing".but you made lemonade from lemons.I was up until 3am so upset. but life goes on.i wish you all the success in life..God Bless Your Real Good.i am praying for you,babe.I think you were "robbed".You are a wonderful person,Dan.Love ya,kid !!
Butch Rulfs - 2:42 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
The judges were wrong!!! Dan is the winner. Is it true that he could have his own show if voted the best by us (on-line viewers)??? Where do we vote???
Nan - 2:30 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
Here's the link to vote for your favorite Design Star. Voting ends at 3 p.m. Mountain Time Tuesday. http://www.hgtv.com/hgtv-design-star-vote-for-your-favorite-designer-results/package/index.html
Vickie Holbrook - 2:38 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
I hope Dan reads the overwhelmingly negative response to the judges decision on the HGTV Design Star blogs - some small consolation at least for the person whose designs were consistently clearly superior. He should have won.
Star - 1:20 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
Though I wanted Dan to win, I knew Antonio was going to win. When I heard that they were having the judges make the final decision, I knew that HGTV wanted to be able to control who won. And as I watched, it was clear that Antonion was the most anti-HGTV guy and that he would probably win if he had any talent at all. If the "people" could have chose, Dan definitely WOULD have won. And I'm sure he will win the online show. He's the best!
Kathy - 12:31 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
Dan, My heart was pounding as I waited for the judges decision, when I heard I was in disbelief, tears welled up in my eyes. You were clearly the winner. I will not be watching Antiono's show as I am not into biker dude types,I'm a great grand ma and I seriously doubt that very few if any people my age will be watching him.I love your the boy next door persona, and the way you listen to and execute the design that the client wants. I'm so glad to hear you and Lonni are good friends. I also got it when Torie told you she was giving you 10k in the van and Antonio made a comment on the 10k. Just know there are thousands of us out here that know you are not dishonest, and I will continue to vote for you until the end. I'm so sorry to hear about your grandpa, I'm sure he is smiling down on you, and saying job well done. Good luck, and I'm pulling for you.
Linda L. - 12:27 PM, Monday September 14, 2009
Dan, you did your grandfather and family proud! I would have moved into the Goldberg home in a New York minute! It was so calm and serene...the perfect place to come home to. Good luck in your future endeavors.
Andrea - 11:49 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
Dan, You by far were the winner in my book. I know that if I hired you to design a room (or a house for that matter) for me, I could trust you with it and know that your ultimate goal would be to give me what would please me and my family, with class and with style, not what was edgy or 'close to offensive'. You are the real design star and my prayers are with you for a successful future.
Mel - 10:55 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
I was stunned when the announcement was made that Antonio had won. I can't believe that his image is going to attract many hgtv viewers. Dan's the man! I hope Dan's recent exposure, contacts and future career choices bring him amazing success. I know things usually work out for a reason--so it makes me wonder if Dan's not meant for a bigger career than hgtv could have given him...??? I hope he'll explore ALL his options and think outside the box! The camera loves him, the audience loves him and we love him in Kansas!!!
Jeff in Kansas - 9:13 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
Dan, I am sure you are right, we will see your face again on tv, maybe even HGTV. They'de be even more foolish than they are behaving presently to let you get away. About a week ago I wrote in your aunt's blog and since that time took the opportunity to read a few more articles about the competition, several by Lonni. I am sad to realize how much I was manipulated by film editing. As more of the actual contents of the different challenges came to my attention, the more aware I have become of feeling slightly deceived by certain forces at HGTV. I am sure it cannot be all of them, at least I hope not. I can tell from your comments and designs, that although you are only 26, as well as being a superior designer, you also have a keenly defined sense about people, which was more than apparent in your beautiful, thoughtful and ingenious design for the sweet ladies. I am guessing you get the big picture of the what some at HGTV have tried to create in this contest for "entertainment's" sake. I think it will backfire on them. The irony is that they have educated us all so well in great design and its execution with people like, Candice, Vern, John G., Lee S., Lisa La., David B. that we KNOW and RESPECT good design when we see it, and we also KNOW when we've been had. YOU BELONG IN THE GROUP ABOVE, and don't let anyone convince you otherwise. Nothing against Antonio, he's his own guy, he's his own style, and he won their type of "competition", but you won ours. If you doubt me, read the HGTV blogs. Congratulations,and the LORD heap your rewards upon you. YOU'RE the people's winner. Many blessings!!!
Suzanne - 8:39 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
Hey, Dan, Just wanted to let you know that I was rooting for you to win from the first episode. I am literally sick at heart about the results of Design Star. You were robbed. Your designs were beautiful and practical and inspiring...and you listened to the homeowners and gave them personalized touches in a space they'll love for years to come. Your white room challenge WAS the absolute best I've seen during 4 years of Design Star. Obviously, the network had already decided to choose Antonio before the competition even began (heaven only knows why) and nothing you could've done would have changed the outcome. I would have watched your show and learned so much about design, and I'm sad for the missed opportunity. I most certainly won't be watching "Hey, Yo, Wassup... Let's Trash Dis House," with Antonio. (And if the flaming message boards at HGTV right now are any indication, neither will 9 out of 10 of their very irate audience.) I don't understand why HGTV thinks rude and incoherent is "refreshing." I know you'll go on to have a long and very successful career, because you have true talent and are a kind, generous & caring individual. Best of luck from a fellow Portlander, and sincere condolences on the loss of your beloved Grandpa.
Di - 1:52 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
I was so shocked at the outcome, I thought for sure it would go the other way. Dan your designs are beautiful and I would be glad to watch any show you hosted, you can be proud of all you did on the show.
istersay - 1:44 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
Congratulations Dan You did an excellent job made to lovely ladies very happy and gave america great joy watching you. You are now and always will be a Design Star!! There is a right place for you in the design world and you will soon be there and you will know its right for YOU!! Just like the lady said on yur reveal tonight "it will feel like home" Love and Prayers for your success you made it a joyful ride!!! Jeani Metcalf
Jeani Metcalf - 1:15 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
Hi Dan, Bethiekc here. So disappointed you didn't win and hope HGTV comes to realize you have a serious fan base that want to see you have your own show. You should see the blogs on HGTV website! Best of Luck to you and your family and so sorry for the loss of your Grandfather. GB/GL and look forward to seeing more of you and your successful designs in the future.
Beth - 12:56 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
Well, I have commented on HGTV's blog. I saw a link for this recently released article and I had to leave my two cents again. Dan, you're amazing. Your room for the Priestly's was stunnng, and I hate nautical rooms... and blue for that matter! It almost made me want to adopt a baby boy and hire you to recreate your room in my house. Almost. I was glad to read that you're optimistic about your chances with HGTV, but I'd encourage you to look outside of a network that has twice dropped the ball, in regards to you. Why should they get to profit from you? We'll follow you no matter which network YOU CHOOSE to work for. After they read the scathing comments left at HGTV I think you'll be getting some intriguing offers from previously untapped sources. Good luck with your no doubt brilliant career. We all love you! ---Keith p.s. I loved the bed you designed for the girl's room tonight. I may have to adopt a girl her age too!
Keith Lukowski - 12:31 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
Dan, I was rooting for you the whole way. Your white room challenge design was fantastic as were many other design solutions you came up with. I'm so sorry about your grandfather, and how tough that you had to do the final challenge with that grief. I certainly don't understand the judges decision as I thought both you and Lonnie were far, far better than Antonio, who rubbed many of us the wrong way... just read the comments on HGTV's website. I'm sure that if viewers had voted for the winner as in past seasons, you would have won. I'd love to see a show starring you and Lonnie, that would be fun. I won't be watching Antonio's show, that's for sure. And as an Oregonian (currently in Bend), I'm so proud of you... in fact, we go through Vale every time we visit our son in Boise. You've got to be the most famous person from Vale now! Good luck, and I'm voting for you online. -Cleo
Cleo - 12:09 AM, Monday September 14, 2009
Dan, you did an excellent job and had really appealing designs for the duration of the show and certainly deserved to win in my opinion. You have every right to be proud of your achievements and keep up the excellent work. Also, never lose that laugh. It's great and contagious. :-) Best of luck to you. Also, I am sorry to hear about your grandfather. My condolences to you and your family.
Lance - 11:19 PM, Sunday September 13, 2009
Enjoyed each episode of this year's DESIGNSTAR... however, I had planned to watch it tonight- in another hour here in Arizona, and I just read THIS- that ANTONIO was the winner- prior to the show being aired HERE.... hmmm All 4 of the finalists did some outstanding work....and they all made some mistakes along the way, as they are all human! Grace under pressure- working when one is exhausted and in the spotlight is never easy.... you FINAL FOUR should all take a bow! Great show- HGTV.... AUNT VICKIE__ wish I could have seen the last show before I read your blog, kiddo```- but-- oh wellllllllll
Vicki Sheley - 10:55 PM, Sunday September 13, 2009
This is truly crazy to me that Dan didn't win, simply because I had faith that HGTV had better taste than they apparently do! I'm glad to see that he's staying so upbeat, though, because his good humor and ability to handle such hardships will be able to get him through his dreams. Even with his grandfather's death, he managed to 'suck it up' and try to hold out for at least the rest of the challenge. And that's AMAZING. Dan: Thank you, good job, and good luck.
Diana - 10:45 PM, Sunday September 13, 2009
Vickie, thatnks so much for keeping us all up on the current events with Dan... I realize it is all filmed way in advance but it is still a big let down tonight. Well, hopefully this means online show (or even better!) will be in near future for Dan... All the best from designer in south Texas, Rick Shuster
RickS - 10:40 PM, Sunday September 13, 2009
Dan, I've been rooting for you all season and voting for you all season, so I can only hope that you win the Online show because I will watch every single episode! You totally deserve it after trying for *two seasons* to win - one can't help but respect you for that. Congratulations on getting so far while remaining an honest person. From Jennifer in Columbus, Ohio. :)
Jennifer - 10:40 PM, Sunday September 13, 2009


If you Log in or Register you will not be required to fill this out each time you comment.
Name:
Email Address: Will not be published.
Comment [max. 5000 chars.] Character Count:

Vickie Schaffeld-Holbrook
Vickie has worked at the Idaho Press-Tribune since 1979. In her free time, she loves to share her ideas when it comes to home and garden.
Idaho Press-Tribune on Facebook
IPT Community Calendar
<< >>
SMTWTFS
01020304050607
08091011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930          
Submit your event - FREE!
http://www.linkedin.com/pub/4/955/980
Blog Admin login
Username:
Password: